Punishing Mrs. J: Gender in WOMAN ON THE RUN

Flicker Alley is proud to present the following essay by BNoirDetour, written for Detectives and Dames: A Flicker Alley Noir Blog-a-Thon! Woman on the Run (1950) is available on Blu-ray/DVD May 10! Pre-order today!

Note: This essay contains spoilers for Woman on the Run.


Woman on the Run_title card_color

Critics are right to note the virgin/whore dichotomy in women’s roles within film noir. The most identifiable female noir characters are the femme fatale and the devoted girlfriend/wife. In the cynical, criminal world of noir, women are generally either ruthless seductresses or innocent maintainers of hearth and home.The femme fatale destroys family; the good wife protects it. Of the two types, feminist critics (e.g. the authors in Women in Film Noir) have tended to emphasize the strong, active role of the femme fatale compared to the more passive girlfriend/wife. Yet the bad girl must be punished as a threat to the traditional gender hierarchy: men lead and women follow. Upsetting this order necessitates condemnation of the gender traitor, so the femme fatale faces penalties from isolation to imprisonment to death. Some women’s roles, of course, do not fit within this narrow binary absolute. Imogen Sarah Smith, in the Winter 2015 issue of Noir City, discusses the noir “working girl,” an active and independent figure nonetheless devoted to men (usually one in particular) based on the Hawksian woman – e.g. Rosalind Russell in His Girl Friday or Ella Raines in Phantom Lady. She reflects well the changing status of white, middle-class women during the WWII era without invoking paranoia of emasculation. Yet such paranoia is central to film noir, as is anxiety over race and nation related to the war.

This background of reactionary fears alongside unavoidable post-war cultural change explains much about the character of Mrs. Eleanor Johnson (Ann Sheridan) in Woman on the Run (1950). Mrs. Johnson is neither femme fatale nor good wife nor working girl. Her attitude toward her husband Frank (Ross Elliott) is one of scorn and derision for his combination of wanderlust and inability to succeed as an artist despite ample talent. Mrs. Johnson is not surprised that her husband has run off after being shot at when witnessing a murder late one night. She explains to the earnest, well-meaning Inspector Ferris (Robert Keith) that he was fleeing her as much as the police; he is a man, she claims, who runs away from everything. Ferris inquires whether she ever attempted to get a job to help support them as her husband worked at his painting. Her reply is one we expect to hear from a heartless gold-digger: “Why should I?” Soon, her contemptuousness and haughty attitude drive Ferris to pose the rhetorical question, “Mrs. Johnson, didn’t your husband ever beat you?”

Woman on the Run_007_large

Ann Sheridan and Robert Keith in Woman on the Run.

Eleanor Johnson is not easy to like throughout much of the film, nor is she meant to be. We meet men and women alike with whom her husband interacts daily, and all report him to be kind, patient, generous and caring. Only his wife harbors such ill-will . . . well, she and Danny-boy (Dennis O’Keefe), the murderer who uses her to find her hiding spouse. Eleanor acts against her own best interests and that of her husband because she is blind to what she sees as weakness in him. Vulnerability seems to disgust her, but so do strong men. Not knowing he is the killer sought by police, she confides in Dan, posing as a reporter, because he promises not only to help her but to pay Frank money for exclusive rights to his story. Rejecting the help of the police, she tells Dan, “I’ve had just about enough of the all-wise male.”

Through her efforts to find Frank and give him the heart medicine he desperately needs, Eleanor eventually comes to see her husband as a man she should love and support but has not. “A lot of it’s my fault,” she admits to Ferris. “I haven’t been much of a wife.” Ferris acknowledges her confession with affectionate condescension, “That’s quite an admission from you, Mrs. J.” But admitting her failure is not enough. This is noir, and although she is no black widow and has not been unfaithfulone wonders if she has any sexual appetite at all, actuallyshe has been a bad wife and her penance requires stronger measures than an expression of guilt and a few snide remarks from a kind police officer.

The scene most praised for its uniqueness in Woman on the Run is the roller coaster ride. The tension is high as Mrs. J rides with the killer beside her up the tracks and down, the fear and guilt she already has heightened by the adrenaline-exhausting circular trip. Then, when she finally realizes who Dan is, she is stuck riding the coaster a second time, full of utter terror and panic as the world spins and dips around her while her husband is stalked by a sociopath.

Woman on the Run roller coaster Ann SheridanWithin the context of gender analysis, can we read this scene otherwise than the ungrateful wife’s deserved punishment? Certainly, she faces a form of torture it is painful to watch. And watch we must, for the camera is centered on her horrified, shattered expression and her body being thrown across the seat like a rag doll. Moreover, once she survives this harrowing ordeal, she hears a gunshot which she assumes kills her husband. Inspector Ferris soonbut not immediatelytells her the man floating limply in the water is not her husband but the murderer. He then tells her where to find Frank.

Mrs. J is no femme fatale, but her mistreatment in the film’s climactic moments suggest that her threat to men is just as great. This woman has not shown her husband respect, proper wifely submission, or even the abiding support of a spunky working girl. Only once she has been tormented, both emotionally and physically, can she earn a permanent return to her husband’s loving arms.

Ultimately, Woman on the Run can be read as highly reflective of post-war Hollywood as it gives way to the suffocating atmosphere of the 1950s. If we agree with the film’s judgment and join in the punishing of Mrs. J, it is because she is the protagonist whose perspectivewritten, directed and filmed by menwe are given. Because this offers so bleak a prescription, let me end this post on another note. Note that the husband-wife embrace does not end the picture. After they clasp one another as strangers encircle them on the midway, the camera retreats, pulling away and then stopping on the figure of a grotesque female mechanical clown that cackles madly to end the film. We saw and heard her laughter earlier in the film, especially as Eleanor was whipped about on the ride. Cruel fate mocks us. Yet, to me, this choice for a final image is more specifically suggestive. I find it a welcome carnivalesque moment, a final commentary on the gender roles we have just seen as not only laughably ridiculous but more than a little creepy.

Woman on the Run Laffing Sal


Remember to pre-order Too Late for Tears and Woman on the Run and save 25% off MSRP while the sale lasts!

For more exclusive essays, film preservation news, and special discounts, sign up for the Flicker Alley Newsletter.

 

13.4.2016
 

Comments are closed.